Welcome to Drishti Judiciary - Powered by Drishti IAS









Home / Constitution of India

Constitutional Law

Sources of the Constitutional Law in India

    «
 03-Dec-2024

Introduction 

  • Constitutional law in India represents a complex and multifaceted legal framework that draws from various historical, legal, and philosophical sources.  
  • Understanding these sources is crucial for comprehending the constitutional structure and legal principles governing the world's largest democracy. 
  • Constitutional law is a body of law that governs the interpretation and implementation of a country's constitution.  
  • It serves as the supreme law of the land, establishing the framework for government, delineating the powers of various branches, and protecting the rights of individuals.  
  • The sources of constitutional law are diverse and can be categorized into primary and secondary sources.  

Primary Sources of Constitutional Law 

  • The Constitution of India (1950) (COI):
    • The primary and most fundamental source of constitutional law in India is the Constitution itself, which came into effect on 26th  January 1950. It is: 
      • A written, comprehensive document. 
      • The supreme law of the land. 
      • Providing the basic framework for governance. 
      • Defining the structure of government, fundamental rights, and directive principles. 
    • Key Characteristics: 
      • Longest written constitution in the world.  
      • Drawn from multiple global constitutional experiences. 
      • Flexible yet fundamentally robust. 
  • Constitutional Amendments: 
    • Article 368 of the COI provides the mechanism for constitutional amendments.  
    • These amendments are critical sources of constitutional law, allowing the document to: 
      • Adapt to changing social and political circumstances. 
      • Resolve ambiguities. 
      • Expand or modify existing provisions. 
    • Significant amendments have addressed the following:  
      • Fundamental rights 
      • Centre-State relations 
      • Judicial review 
      • Socio-economic transformations
  • Judicial Pronouncements and Precedents:
    • The Indian judiciary, particularly the Supreme Court, plays a pivotal role in interpreting and developing constitutional law through: 
    • Landmark Judgments: 
      • Provide authoritative interpretations of constitutional provisions. 
      • Resolve conflicts in constitutional understanding. 
      • Establish precedents for future cases. 
    • Judicial Review: 
      • Power to examine the constitutional validity of legislative and executive actions. 
      • Ensures compliance with constitutional principles. 
      • Protects fundamental rights. 

Secondary Sources of Constitutional Law 

  • Historical Documents and Influences: 
  • Government of India Act, 1935: 
    • Significant pre-constitutional legislative document.  
    • Provided structural inspiration for the Indian Constitution. 
    • Influenced administrative and federal frameworks. 
    • Various principles and provisions of this act were adopted for framing of the constitution such as:  
      • Division of Powers.  
      • Provincial Autonomy  
      • Bicameralism 
    • Colonial Legal Traditions: 
      • British parliamentary system 
      • Common law principles 
      • Administrative law concepts 
  • International Conventions and Treaties: 
    • While not directly binding, international legal instruments significantly influence constitutional interpretation: 
      • Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) 
      • International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) 
      • UN Conventions on Human Rights and Social Justice (UCHRSJ) 
  • Scholarly Writings and Commentaries: 
    • Constitutional law scholarship contributes to: 
      • Interpretation of constitutional provisions 
      • Understanding historical context 
      • Analyzing judicial pronouncements 
      • Proposing legal reforms 
      • Eminent scholars like M.P. Jain, Granville Austin, and Nani Palkhivala have made substantial contributions. 

Internation Sources of the Constitution Law 

  • Several features of the Indian Constitution have been adopted from various constitutions of different countries which are listed below: 
Country Borrowed Features
United Kingdom

Parliamentary System: Westminster model of democracy 

Rule of Law: British constitutional tradition 

Legislative Procedure: Parliamentary law-making process Ministerial Responsibility: Cabinet system 

Prerogative Writs: Judicial review mechanisms 

United States

Fundamental Rights: Inspired by the US Bill of Rights 

Judicial Review: Power of courts to review laws  

Federal Structure: Bicameral legislature 

Preamble: Philosophical ideals 

Impeachment Procedures: Mechanisms for removing officials 

Ireland

Directive Principles of State Policy: Socio-economic guidelines 

Presidential Nomination Method: Similar process 

Use of Directive Principles: Governance framework 

Canada

Federal Structure: Centre-state relations 

Division of Powers: Distribution between central and state governments 

Emergency Provisions: Governance flexibility during crises 

Australia

Concurrent List: Shared legislative powers 

Freedom of Trade: Economic integration provisions 

Role of State Governors: Appointment and functions

Germany

Fundamental Duties: Concept of citizen responsibilities  

Social Welfare Provisions: Emphasis on social justice 

Soviet Union

Fundamental Duties: Socialist principles 

Commitment to Social Justice: Welfare state ideology 

France

Republic Concept: Secular and democratic principles 

Liberty, Equality, Fraternity: Philosophical inspiration 

Russia (Soviet Union)

Fundamental Duties: Directly inspired by Soviet constitutional principles 

Socialist Principles: Collective welfare concepts 

State-Directed Development: Focus on planned economic growth 

South Africa

Transformative Constitution: Social justice and equality Multicultural Framework: Recognition of diverse societal groups 

Comprehensive Rights Protection: Extensive bill of rights 

Japan Peaceful Democratic Model: Commitment to non-violence Post-War Constitutional Design: Institutional restructuring Democratic Governance: Strong checks and balances 

Conclusion 

The sources of constitutional law in India represent a dynamic, evolving legal ecosystem. They reflect the nation's complex historical journey, democratic aspirations, and commitment to justice, equality, and human dignity. The interplay between the written constitution, judicial interpretations, amendments, and broader legal traditions ensures that Indian constitutional law remains responsive to societal changes while maintaining fundamental constitutional principles.