-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
Home / Current Affairs
Civil Law
Deposit After Decree Cannot Revive Right to Defend Under Order XXXVII CPC
« »16-Nov-2026
Source: Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court
Why in News?
Justice Moksha Khajuria Kazmi of the Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court decided UT of J&K v. Shabir Ahmad Dar (2026). The Court dismissed a Civil First Appeal against a decree passed in a summary suit under Order XXXVII CPC.
The Court held that:
- Leave to defend granted subject to a deposit must be complied with within the time the trial court fixes.
- A deposit made after the decree cannot be treated as compliance retrospectively, and it does not revive the right to defend.
- When the condition is not met in time, the trial court commits no illegality in decreeing the suit.
What was the Background of the UT of J&K v. Shabir Ahmad Dar (2026) Case?
The works: The plaintiffs said they had carried out electrical works worth ₹37.82 lakh at the MLA Hostel, Srinagar. The Legislative Assembly Secretariat, J&K, contributed the funds and released them to the Directorate of Estates to meet the cost. No public tenders were invited for the works.
The suit: The plaintiffs filed a summary suit under Order XXXVII CPC to recover the money due for the works.
Leave to defend: The Estates Department applied for leave to defend. The trial court granted leave on two conditions:
- The appellants were to deposit ₹37.82 lakh before the court.
- They were to file a written statement within thirty days.
Challenge to the condition: The appellants challenged the condition before the High Court in a petition. The petition was dismissed.
Partial deposit:
- After the petition was dismissed, the appellants deposited ₹19,01,000 by cheque on 26.03.2023.
- For the rest, they asked the Treasury Officer for details of available funds.
The decree: The condition was not met within the time allowed. On 12.08.2023, the Additional District Judge (Bank Cases), Srinagar, decreed the suit for ₹57.23 lakh with interest and costs.
Later deposit: The balance of ₹18,81,000 was deposited on 25.07.2025, almost two years after the decree.
What the appellants argued:
- A substantial part of the amount had already been deposited.
- The trial court ignored the peculiar circumstances that delayed depositing the rest.
What the respondents argued:
- In their application for leave to defend, the appellants had admitted that works worth ₹37.82 lakh were carried out.
- The appellants did not comply with the condition in time, and paid the balance only in 2025, long after the decree.
Questions before the High Court:
- Was the trial court right to decree the suit when the deposit condition attached to leave to defend was not met?
- Can a deposit made after the decree count as compliance and revive the right to defend?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On compliance with the condition:
- The trial court had granted leave on the condition that ₹37.82 lakh be deposited and a written statement filed within thirty days.
- Only ₹19,01,000 was deposited within that period. The balance of ₹18,81,000 was deposited on 25.07.2025.
- It was an admitted position that the suit was decreed on 12.08.2023, well before the balance was deposited.
On the delay:
- The appellants gave no cogent explanation for failing to deposit the balance within the time granted.
On the decree:
- Since the condition was not fulfilled, the trial court committed no illegality in decreeing the suit.
On retrospective compliance:
- A deposit made after the decree cannot be treated as compliance with the direction after the fact, so it cannot revive the right to defend.
Decision
- The deposit made after the decree did not revive the right to defend.
- The Court found no perversity or illegality in the trial court’s judgment and decree.
- The decree for ₹57.23 lakh with interest and costs was upheld.
- The Civil First Appeal was dismissed.
What is the Legal Position on Leave to Defend Under Order XXXVII CPC?
- Nature of summary suits: Order XXXVII CPC provides a summary procedure for suits on bills of exchange, hundis, promissory notes and written contracts, and for recovering a debt or liquidated sum. Its purpose is to stop defendants from delaying the recovery of clear dues.
- No automatic right to defend: In a summary suit, the defendant cannot defend as of right. Under Order XXXVII Rule 3, the defendant must enter appearance and then apply for leave to defend.
- Grant of leave (Rule 3(5)): The court may grant leave unconditionally, or on terms such as a deposit or security. It may refuse leave if the defence is frivolous or vexatious, or if there is no substantial defence.
- Admitted amount (proviso to Rule 3(5)): If the defendant admits that part of the claimed amount is due, leave to defend cannot be granted unless that admitted amount is deposited in court. This is relevant here, since the appellants had admitted works worth ₹37.82 lakh.
- Failure to comply (Rule 3(6)): If the defendant does not give the security or carry out the other directions on which leave was granted, the plaintiff becomes entitled to judgment at once.
- Supreme Court position: In IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. v. Hubtown Ltd. (2016), the Supreme Court restated the principles for granting leave to defend under the amended Order XXXVII, replacing the earlier guidelines in Mechelec Engineers & Manufacturers v. Basic Equipment Corporation (1976). It held that conditional leave, such as a deposit, may be imposed where the defence raises a triable issue but the court doubts the defendant’s good faith.
