-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
Home / Current Affairs
Civil Law
Third Party Claiming Title Not a Necessary Party in Eviction Suit
«17-Nov-2026
Source: Allahabad High Court
Why in News?
Justice Dr. Yogendra Kumar Srivastava decided Smt. Chandri Devi & Another v. Smt. Lalita Chauhan & Another (2026). The Court dismissed a revision against an order refusing to implead third parties in an eviction suit.
The Court also held:
- A third party claiming independent ownership, title, tenancy or possession does not become a necessary or proper party to an eviction suit just because the decree may affect that claim.
- The same applies to a claim based on a tenancy said to have arisen after the suit was filed.
- An independent dispute over title or tenancy cannot ordinarily be brought into an eviction suit through Order I Rule 10 CPC, unless deciding it is necessary to decide the suit.
What was the Background of the Smt. Chandri Devi v. Smt. Lalita Chauhan (2026) Case?
The eviction suit:
- In 2018, respondent no. 1 sued respondent no. 2 for eviction from commercial premises at Village Sadarpur, Dadri, Gautam Buddh Nagar, and for arrears of rent. She pleaded that he was her tenant.
- Respondent no. 2 denied being her tenant or in possession. He said that one Manoj ran a business there as the tenant of revisionist no. 1.
The revisionists’ claims:
- Revisionist no. 1 claimed to have executed a sale deed dated 22 July 2016 in favour of respondent no. 1 for 100 square yards. She has filed Original Suit No. 38 of 2018 to have it cancelled.
- The revisionists said Manoj was revisionist no. 1’s tenant until 31 December 2019.
- Revisionist no. 2 claimed to have been inducted as a tenant from 1 January 2020 to run coaching classes.
Proceedings below:
- The revisionists applied under Order I Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC to be impleaded as defendants.
- The Additional District Judge rejected the application because:
- nothing on record showed the alleged tenancy;
- the registered sale deed had not been declared void; and
- the question of title fell outside a suit limited to the landlord-tenant relationship.
- The revisionists then filed a revision under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887.
Question before the High Court:
- Could third parties claiming independent ownership or tenancy over the premises be impleaded in a pending eviction suit?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On the scope of Order I Rule 10(2) CPC:
- The provision exists to enable a complete decision of the controversy actually before the Court.
- Relying on Kanaklata Das & Others v. Naba Kumar Das & Others, the Court said the landlord and the tenant are ordinarily the only necessary parties to an eviction suit.
- A third party does not become a necessary or proper party just by asserting an independent claim of ownership, title, interest or possession of the suit premises.
- The same applies to an independent tenancy, including one said to have arisen after the suit was filed.
- An independent dispute over ownership, title, possession or a separate tenancy cannot ordinarily be brought into an eviction suit, unless deciding it is shown to be necessary to decide the suit.
On revisionist no. 1’s ownership claim:
- Her claim of ownership was an independent dispute, already pending in Original Suit No. 38 of 2018.
- The validity of the sale deed did not need to be decided to settle the landlord-tenant dispute in the eviction suit.
On revisionist no. 2’s tenancy claim:
- The tenancy he claimed from 1 January 2020 began after the suit was filed. It did not change the dispute as it stood when the suit was filed.
- The GST, VAT and sales tax registrations he relied on did not establish any tenancy in his favour.
Clarification:
- Refusing impleadment did not decide any of the revisionists’ independent claims.
- The Court expressed no opinion on Original Suit No. 38 of 2018, the sale deed or the alleged tenancy.
Decision
- The revision was dismissed.
- The order rejecting the impleadment application was upheld.
- The revisionists remain free to pursue their independent claims in the proper proceedings.
What is Impleadment under Order I Rule 10 CPC?
Meaning:
- Impleadment means adding a person as a party (plaintiff or defendant) to a pending suit.
- Under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC, the Court may, at any stage, on application or on its own, add any person who ought to have been joined, or whose presence is necessary for it to decide all the questions in the suit effectively and completely.
- It may also strike out the name of any party who has been improperly joined.
Necessary party vs proper party:
- Necessary party: A person against whom relief is sought, and without whom no effective decree can be passed. If a necessary party is not joined, the suit fails.
- Proper party: A person whose presence is not essential but helps the Court decide all the questions in the suit completely. If a proper party is not joined, the suit does not fail.
Principles governing impleadment:
- The plaintiff is dominus litis: they choose whom to sue and cannot ordinarily be forced to litigate against someone they do not wish to sue.
- A person cannot be added just because they have an interest in the subject matter or may be indirectly affected by the decree.
- Impleadment cannot be used to turn a suit into a different suit or bring in an unrelated dispute.
Eviction suits:
- An eviction suit is limited to the landlord-tenant relationship and the grounds for eviction.
- Questions of title between the landlord and a stranger are outside its scope and must be decided in separate proceedings.
Revision under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887:
- The High Court may examine a decree or order of a Small Causes Court to satisfy itself that it was made according to law.
Key precedents:
- Mumbai International Airport (P) Ltd. v. Regency Convention Centre & Hotels (P) Ltd. (2010): The Supreme Court explained the difference between necessary and proper parties. It held that the plaintiff, as dominus litis, cannot ordinarily be compelled to add a person against whom no relief is sought.
- Kanaklata Das v. Naba Kumar Das (2018): The Supreme Court held that in an eviction suit the landlord and the tenant are the only necessary parties, and that title disputes with third parties are outside its scope.
