Home / Editorial

Criminal Law

Bilkis Bano Case: Supreme Court Suspends Life Sentences of Two Convicts

    «
 17-Nov-2026

    Tags:
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS)

Source: The Hindu 

Introduction 

The Supreme Court has granted bail to two men serving life sentences for the gang rape of Bilkis Bano and the murder of members of her family, including a two-month-old infant, during the 2002 riots. A Bench of Justice M.M. Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B. Varale suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya on October 28. The States of Gujarat and Maharashtra opposed bail, citing the seriousness of the offence.

What did the Supreme Court Order? 

  • The Court suspended the life sentences of the two appellants and granted them bail. 
  • The short order, recently published on the Court's website, gave these reasons:  
    • The two men had already been in prison for more than 17 years. 
    • One of them has a severe disability. 
    • The appeal raises issues to be decided on both fact and law. 
  • Bail was granted on conditions to be imposed by the trial court.

What were the Arguments Before the Court? 

For the appellants: 

  • Senior Advocate Siddharth Luthra appeared for the appellants. 
  • He argued that Modhiya had not been named in the FIR and was implicated only after nearly three years. 
  • Joshi, who had undergone leg surgery, was described as having a disability. 

For the States of Gujarat and Maharashtra: 

  • Additional Solicitor-General Raja Thakre and counsel for the two States, Swati Ghildayal and Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, opposed bail. 
  • They argued that the offence was very serious and that the High Court had confirmed the convictions.

What is the Background of the Bilkis Bano Case? 

  • August 2004: The Supreme Court transferred the case from Gujarat to Maharashtra. It noted that Bilkis Bano had been forced to live like a nomad and an orphan, and that the violence had left a lasting mark on her mind. 
  • January 2008: A CBI Special Judge in Greater Mumbai convicted 11 men and sentenced them to life imprisonment. 
  • The High Court later confirmed the convictions. 
  • August 2022: The State of Gujarat granted remission to all 11 convicts together. 
  • 2024: The Supreme Court quashed Gujarat's remission order.

What is Suspension of Sentence Pending Appeal? 

  • When a convict appeals, the appellate court may, for reasons recorded in writing, suspend the sentence and release the convict on bail while the appeal is pending. 
  • This power was earlier under Section 389 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. It is now under Section 430 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. 
  • Suspending a sentence does not set aside the conviction. It only defers the sentence until the appeal is decided. 
  • Courts commonly consider:  
    • how long the convict has already spent in custody; 
    • whether the appeal is likely to be heard soon; 
    • whether the appeal raises arguable issues; 
    • how serious the offence is; and 
    • the convict's age, health and other personal circumstances. 
  • Where a convict has served a long period and the appeal is unlikely to be heard soon, courts lean towards suspending the sentence.

Conclusion 

In suspending the life sentences of two convicts, the Supreme Court balanced the gravity of the crime against the long time they have already spent in prison, the disability of one of them, and the arguable issues of fact and law in their appeal. Bail pending appeal does not decide guilt or innocence. It recognises that a convict should not serve almost the whole sentence before the appeal is heard. Still, given the gravity of the crimes and the case's long history, from its transfer out of Gujarat to the quashing of the 2022 remission, the order will draw close attention as the appeal goes forward.