-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
Home / Editorial
Constitutional Law
Transgender Rights and Healthcare under the 2026 Amendment Act
«18-Nov-2026
Source: The Hindu
Introduction
Earlier this year, Parliament passed the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026, a major change to the 2019 Act. The amendment does away with self-identification. Legal recognition now depends on a medical board’s recommendation, the choice of a prescribed category, and certification by a District Magistrate.
The authors are physicians, public health practitioners and activists. They accept that the Act increases protection in some respects. However, they argue that it shifts the basis of transgender rights from autonomy and self-identification to recognition granted by medical and administrative authorities.
What Changes under the 2026 Amendment Act?
- End of self-identification: A person can no longer be legally recognised as transgender on the basis of self-identification alone.
- Medical board recommendation: Recognition now requires a recommendation from a medical board.
- Prescribed categories: The person must fall within one of a restricted set of categories.
- Certification: The District Magistrate certifies the person’s identity.
- Narrower definition: Trans men, trans women and genderqueer persons are removed from the statutory definition of “transgender”. The definition now covers certain socio-cultural identities (such as kinner, hijra, aravani, jogta and eunuch) and persons with specified variations in sex characteristics.
How Does the Act Create Medico-Legal Hurdles?
Conflict with international standards:
- The authors say the new definition contradicts international evidence and guidelines, including the World Health Organization’s ICD-11 and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) Standards of Care Version 8.
Conflation of two separate issues:
- The Act mixes up two questions: whether a person’s gender identity is legally valid, and whether the person is eligible for welfare benefits.
- It makes a medical authority the gatekeeper of gender identity.
Return of the psychiatric model:
- The Supreme Court has held that gender identity is part of personal autonomy and dignity under Article 21, and rejected the idea that it should depend on medical intervention.
- The authors argue that the Act revives a discredited psychiatric model, under which an internal and social identity needs professional certification.
Exclusion of gender-diverse persons:
- People left out of the new definition face a gap between the gender incongruence they experience and the identity the State recognises.
- Some people protected under the 2019 Act lose that protection. Some identities are medicalised, while others are recognised only as cultural categories.
- Even cultural categories now need medical certification. A medical board can assess biological characteristics, but the authors question how it can decide whether someone belongs to a socio-cultural community.
No appeal mechanism:
- The Act provides no effective appeal mechanism or independent review of certification decisions.
How Does the Act Depart from the NALSA Judgment?
What NALSA held:
- In National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (2014), the Supreme Court recognised transgender persons’ right to identity and dignity.
- It recognised the right of every person to self-identify their gender, grounding it in Articles 14, 15, 16, 19(1)(a) and 21 of the Constitution.
The authors’ concerns:
- NALSA took a rights-and-autonomy approach. The authors argue that the 2026 Act takes a paternalistic approach with reduced autonomy.
- This raises a policy question. Should the State protect a marginalised group by adding medico-legal hurdles, or by maximising individual autonomy while providing strong protection against exploitation?
- In the authors’ view, the Act sits uneasily with NALSA’s constitutional reasoning, risks excluding many gender-diverse people, and leaves questions about certification and appeal unresolved.
What are the Public Health Consequences?
Barriers to rights and services:
- The certificate decides access to statutory rights and entitlements, which is why the lack of an appeal process matters.
- The authors say the Act creates barriers to gender-affirming care, documentation, employment, education, social security schemes, insurance and mental health services.
Uncertainty among care providers:
- It is unclear whether gender-affirming and supportive care is legal. As a result, some providers have delayed, suspended or withdrawn services.
Shift to the “grey market”:
- People may turn to unregulated and informal sources, including unqualified private providers, for hormones and surgery.
- This raises the risk of self-medication, post-operative complications, infections, side effects and illness.
- Bureaucratic requirements may also lead to delays and high out-of-pocket costs.
Mental health impact:
- The authors cite emerging evidence from helplines, community consultations and hearings. These show more distress calls from transgender individuals since the amendment, including reports of depression, anxiety, sleep disturbance and suicidal ideation.
What has India Done So Far, and What Does the NHRC Say?
Progress since NALSA:
- Since 2014, the Government has introduced laws, welfare schemes, identity certificates, shelter homes, insurance and healthcare initiatives for the transgender community.
- Even so, transgender persons still face serious discrimination in almost every sector.
NHRC 2026 advisory:
- The National Human Rights Commission’s 2026 advisory lists continuing concerns in education, healthcare, property and inheritance, employment, documentation, policing and grievance redressal.
- The authors say the 2026 Act goes against the NHRC’s recommendations, especially on self-identification, independent grievance mechanisms and reducing documentation barriers.
What are the Challenges in Transgender Healthcare?
Reluctance to seek care:
- Many transgender persons avoid hospitals because of past experiences, fear of judgement, poor understanding among health workers, and concerns about privacy, cost and dignified care.
Need for mainstream care:
- Some hospitals run dedicated transgender clinics offering counselling, hormone therapy and gender-affirming services.
- However, transgender persons also need the full range of care for other conditions, such as diabetes or hypertension, including primary, preventive, emergency, specialist, surgical and dental care.
- The authors argue that transgender healthcare should be part of general healthcare, so patients do not have to look for a “transgender-inclusive” hospital each time.
Gaps in training and implementation:
- Clinical understanding of transgender care needs in India remains very limited.
- Doctors, nurses, receptionists, security staff and administrators need training in basic transgender health.
- The Madras High Court in Sushma (2021) required such education, but the National Medical Commission’s proposed curriculum changes have not included it.
- Hospital forms should allow a patient’s preferred name and gender identity to be recorded, while keeping clinically relevant information.
- Most hospitals have not followed the 2019 Act’s mandate to appoint a Complaints Officer in every establishment.
Conclusion
The authors argue that the 2026 Amendment Act moves legal recognition of transgender persons from self-identification to medical certification, which conflicts with the autonomy-based approach in NALSA. They warn that the narrower definition, the lack of an appeal mechanism, and uncertainty about gender-affirming care are already harming access to services and mental health. They call for inclusive mainstream healthcare, backed by specialised services where needed, and for a response grounded in the dignity of all persons.
