Home / Current Affairs

Criminal Law

Accused Entitled to Complaint Documents Before Cognizance

    «
 19-Nov-2026

    Tags:
  • Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS)

Manoj Kumar Paswan v. State of U.P. & Others 

“The proposed accused shall be entitled, to receive copy of complaint as well as every document annex with and relied upon by the complainant…” 

Justice Santosh Rai 

Source: Allahabad High Court

Why in News? 

Justice Santosh Rai decided Manoj Kumar Paswan v. State of U.P. & Others (2026). The Court allowed an appeal against an order of the Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, which had converted the appellant’s application under Section 173(4) BNSS into a complaint case. 

The Court held: 

  • Before cognizance is taken under Section 223 BNSS, a proposed accused must receive a copy of the complaint and every document annexed to and relied upon by the complainant. 
  • The “opportunity of being heard” under the first proviso to Section 223(1) BNSS is mandatory. It is not limited to an oral hearing and may include written submissions. 
  • An application under Section 173(4) read with Section 175(3) BNSS cannot automatically be converted into a complaint just because the court is not inclined to order an investigation.

What was the Background of the Manoj Kumar Paswan v. State of U.P. (2026) Case? 

The allegations: 

  • The appellant alleged that police personnel abused him by referring to his caste and made objectionable remarks that he belonged to a lower caste. 
  • The police action allegedly arose from his dispute with a neighbour. 
  • He said that complaints made to the police by him and his family members had not led to effective action. 

Proceedings before the Special Judge: 

  • The appellant moved an application under Section 173(4) BNSS seeking police action and investigation. 
  • The Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, directed that the application be registered as a complaint case. 
  • The matter was then listed for recording the complainant’s statement under Section 223 BNSS. 

Proceedings before the High Court: 

  • The appellant challenged the Special Judge’s order in an appeal before the High Court. 

Questions before the High Court: 

  • Can an application under Section 173(4) BNSS be converted into a complaint case merely because the court declines to order an investigation? 
  • What does the proposed accused’s “opportunity of being heard” under Section 223 BNSS include?

What were the Court’s Observations? 

On converting a Section 173(4) application into a complaint: 

  • An application under Section 173(4) read with Section 175(3) BNSS seeking police investigation must be examined on its own merits. 
  • It must not be converted into a complaint automatically just because the court does not wish to order an investigation. 
  • If the court decides to proceed under the complaint procedure, it must record specific reasons, keeping in view the nature of the allegations and the relief sought. 
  • Each application must be examined in light of the allegations, the supporting material and whether a police investigation is needed. The court must also ensure the statutory requirements are met, including that the applicant first approached the Superintendent of Police and filed a duly sworn affidavit. 

On the procedure once an application is treated as a complaint: 

  • The procedure under Sections 223 to 227 BNSS must be strictly followed. 
  • The opportunity under the first proviso to Section 223(1) BNSS is mandatory and must be given before cognizance is taken. 

On the scope of the “opportunity of being heard”: 

  • For the hearing to be effective and meaningful, the proposed accused is entitled to a copy of the complaint and every document annexed to and relied upon by the complainant. 
  • The hearing is not restricted to oral arguments and may include written submissions. 
  • In written submissions, the proposed accused may raise specific legal objections, such as:  
    • lack of territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction; 
    • a legal bar to prosecution; 
    • limitation or a statutory prohibition; 
    • absence of an essential ingredient of the alleged offence; or 
    • that the allegations, even if accepted as stated, do not make out the offence. 
  • The Magistrate must consider material objections and pass a reasoned judicial order. 

On the limits of the pre-cognizance stage: 

  • The Magistrate is not required to hold a mini-trial at this stage. 
  • The court must not undertake a roving inquiry, closely appreciate evidence, or decide disputed defence contentions. 
  • An inquiry under Section 175(3) BNSS is not a full-fledged trial. 
  • An inquiry under Section 225 BNSS must stay confined to whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed against the proposed accused. 

On rejection of a final report: 

  • The same safeguards apply where the investigating officer submits a final report and the court rejects it and treats the matter as a complaint case. 

On complaints against public servants: 

  • Where a complaint is proceeded with against a public servant, the Magistrate must independently examine whether Section 223(2) BNSS applies. 
  • If it applies, the court must obtain a report from the officer superior to the public servant and give the public servant an opportunity to make assertions before taking cognizance. 
  • Sections 175(4) and 223(2) BNSS must not be applied mechanically just because the proposed accused is a public servant. Whether they apply depends on the nature of the allegations and their reasonable connection with the discharge of official duties. 

On complaints arising from civil disputes: 

  • Magistrates must carefully examine cases arising from civil disputes, property disputes, financial or business transactions and earlier litigation. 
  • They must decide whether the allegations independently disclose a criminal offence, or whether the criminal process has been set in motion with mala fide intent. 

On the form of the cognizance order: 

  • Whenever cognizance is taken in a complaint case, the order must expressly record that cognizance has been taken under Section 210(1)(a) BNSS, read with the applicable provisions of Chapter XVI BNSS or any other applicable law. 

On the facts of the case: 

  • The material before the Special Judge did not disclose a prima facie case either for ordering an investigation or for converting the application into a complaint case. 
  • The police had started preventive proceedings against the appellant under Sections 170, 126 and 135 BNSS after a confrontation between him and his neighbour. 
  • No reliable medical evidence supported the specific allegation that the appellant was assaulted with 25–30 blows. 
  • However, the Court clarified that these circumstances could not by themselves be treated as conclusive proof that no offence had been committed.

Decision 

  • The appeal was allowed, and the Special Judge’s order was set aside. 
  • The Court held that the Special Judge had failed to properly examine the material and the statutory safeguards that govern starting criminal proceedings. 
  • The general directions are to be circulated to all judicial officers in Uttar Pradesh through the Registrar General. They are also to be sent to the Director of the Judicial Training and Research Institute (JTRI), Lucknow, for inclusion in judicial training programmes.

What is the Procedure on a Complaint to a Magistrate under the BNSS? 

Meaning of complaint (Section 2(1)(h)): 

  • A complaint is an allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate, so that the Magistrate can act under the Sanhita, that some person has committed an offence. It does not include a police report. 
  • A police report that, after investigation, discloses only a non-cognizable offence is deemed to be a complaint, and the police officer who made it is deemed to be the complainant. 

Cognizance on complaint (Section 210(1)(a)): 

  • A Magistrate may take cognizance of an offence on receiving a complaint of facts that constitute the offence, including a complaint filed by a person authorised under any special law. 

Examination of complainant (Section 223(1)): 

  • A Magistrate taking cognizance on a complaint must examine the complainant and any witnesses present on oath. The substance of the examination is reduced to writing and signed by the complainant, the witnesses and the Magistrate. 
  • First proviso: No cognizance can be taken without giving the accused an opportunity of being heard. 
  • Second proviso: Where the complaint is in writing, the Magistrate need not examine the complainant and witnesses if:  
    • the complaint is made by a public servant acting, or purporting to act, in the discharge of official duties, or by a Court; or 
    • the Magistrate makes over the case to another Magistrate under Section 212. 
  • Third proviso: If the Magistrate makes over the case under Section 212 after examining the complainant and witnesses, the second Magistrate need not examine them again. 

Complaint against a public servant (Section 223(2)): 

A Magistrate cannot take cognizance on a complaint against a public servant for an offence allegedly committed in the course of official functions or duties unless: 

  • the public servant is given an opportunity to make assertions about the situation that led to the alleged incident; and 
  • a report on the facts and circumstances of the incident is received from the officer superior to the public servant. 

Other provisions of Chapter XVI: 

  • Section 224: A Magistrate who is not competent to take cognizance must return a written complaint for presentation to the proper court, or endorse an oral complaint and direct the complainant to the proper court. 
  • Section 225 (Postponement of issue of process): The Magistrate may postpone issuing process and either inquire into the case personally or direct an investigation by a police officer or another person, to decide whether there is sufficient ground to proceed. An investigation cannot be directed where the offence is triable exclusively by the Court of Session. It also cannot be directed where the complaint was not made by a Court, unless the complainant and witnesses present have first been examined on oath. 
  • Section 226 (Dismissal of complaint): If, after considering the statements and the result of any inquiry or investigation, the Magistrate finds no sufficient ground to proceed, the complaint is dismissed with brief reasons recorded. 
  • Section 227 (Issue of process): If there is sufficient ground to proceed, the Magistrate issues summons or a warrant against the accused, as the case requires.