Home / Editorial

Civil Law

Interrogatories under the CPC

    «
 20-Nov-2026

    Tags:
  • Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC)

Introduction 

The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, and other INDIA bloc leaders have applied to the Supreme Court for permission to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission of India (ECI) concerning its Special Intensive Revision (SIR). The questions reportedly ask about approvals by the Chief Election Commissioner and the other Election Commissioners, file records, any recorded dissent, and changes to the electoral rolls. The ECI has objected, and the Court has listed the matter for 9th December 2026.

What are Interrogatories? 

  • Interrogatories are written questions that one party to a case serves on the opposite party, with the court's permission, to get answers on specific facts relevant to the dispute. 
  • They are governed by Order XI of the CPC. 
  • Their purpose is to obtain admissions, clarify disputed facts, avoid unnecessary evidence, and narrow the litigation.

What is the Procedure? 

  • Rule 1: A party may deliver written interrogatories to the opposite party with the court's leave. Only one set can be delivered to the same party without a court order. Questions unrelated to the matters in the suit are treated as irrelevant. 
  • Rule 2: The proposed questions must be placed before the court. The court allows only those necessary for the fair disposal of the suit or for saving costs, and may allow, reject or modify individual questions. 
  • Rule 5: Interrogatories may be served on a member or officer of a corporation or a body that can sue or be sued, which would include the office-bearers of a body like the ECI.

How are They Answered? 

  • Rules 8 and 9: Interrogatories are answered on affidavit within the time allowed. 
  • Rule 6: The responding party may object on grounds such as irrelevance, privilege or scandalous nature. 
  • Rule 7: On an application made within seven days of service, the court may set aside or strike out interrogatories that are vexatious, prolix, oppressive or unnecessary. 
  • Rule 11: If an answer is insufficient, the court may direct a further answer, by affidavit or oral examination.

What Happens if They are Not Answered? 

  • Rule 21: If a party does not comply with an order to answer:  
  • a plaintiff's suit may be dismissed for want of prosecution; and 
  • a defendant's defence may be struck out. 
  • These consequences follow only after notice to the parties and a reasonable opportunity of being heard. 
  • Rule 22: Answers to interrogatories may be used as evidence at trial.

What have the Courts Said? 

  • Raj Narain v. Indira Nehru Gandhi (1972): Only interrogatories reasonably connected to a matter in question are valid. Questions that merely touch the fringe of the dispute are not. The Court also said interrogatories should be encouraged and not lightly denied. 
  • Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin (2012): The right to serve interrogatories should be exercised liberally, to secure material documents and avoid protracted inquiry. 
  • Tara Batra v. Punam A. Kumar (Delhi HC, 2021): Interrogatories cannot be used for fishing inquiries. The court must use its discretion judiciously, and the questions must have a nexus with the dispute.

Can They be Used in Writ Proceedings? 

  • Order XI CPC ordinarily applies to civil suits, and the INDIA bloc's case is a writ proceeding. 
  • The CPC does not automatically apply to writs, but constitutional courts have their own powers to regulate their procedure. 
  • Order XXX of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 applies Order XI CPC only to suits filed before the Supreme Court. 
  • In Raj Narain, interrogatories were applied to election petitions through Section 87 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. 
  • In Kochunni v. State of Madras (1959), the Supreme Court held that a writ petition cannot be dismissed just because it involves disputed facts. The Court may decide those facts on affidavits or, in a proper case, set the matter down for trial on evidence.

Conclusion 

Interrogatories help courts obtain admissions and narrow disputes without lengthy evidence, but they must stay relevant to the core of the case and cannot become fishing expeditions. Because the INDIA bloc's case is a writ proceeding, where the CPC does not apply automatically, the Supreme Court's decision on serving interrogatories on a constitutional body like the Election Commission will matter for how this tool is used in constitutional litigation.