-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
Home / Current Affairs
Family Law
Mother has a Better Prima Facie Claim to Custody of a Child Born to Unwed Parents
« »20-Nov-2026
Source: Supreme Court
Why in News?
A bench of Justice N. Kotiswar Singh and Justice N.V. Anjaria decided Helena Anna Maria Lersch v. State of Goa & Anr. (2026).The case was a custody dispute over a four-year-old boy born to a German mother and an Indian father who were not married to each other.
The Court held:
- In the case of a child born to unwed parents, the mother has a better prima facie claim to custody.
- Unless proved otherwise, the law prefers to give custody to the mother when the parents dispute it.
- The welfare and best interests of the child remain the paramount consideration and override the statutory rights of either parent.
What was the Background of the Helena Anna Maria Lersch v. State of Goa (2026) Case?
The parties:
- The mother is a German national who works in Singapore.
- The father is an Indian national and a practising lawyer.
- The child, a four-year-old boy, was born to them outside marriage.
The dispute:
- The mother asked for interim custody so that she could take the child to Singapore for his education.
- The father opposed this and wanted the child to stay in India in his custody.
- The mother alleged that the father had obstructed her access to the child, and she had repeatedly gone to court to keep her relationship with him.
Pending proceedings:
- The father’s guardianship petition is pending before the Family Court at Patiala House Courts, New Delhi.
Question before the Supreme Court:
- Should interim custody of a child born to unwed parents be given to the mother, and should she be allowed to move the child to Singapore while the guardianship proceedings are pending?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On the test for interim relief:
- The Court applied the triple test for interim relief: prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury.
On the prima facie case (the mother’s preferential right):
- The Court relied on ABC v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2015), which examined the guardianship rights of unwed mothers in different legal systems.
- Section 6(b) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 makes the mother, ahead of the father, the natural guardian of an illegitimate child.
- Mohammedan law also gives the mother a preferential right to custody of an illegitimate child.
- Under the UK Children Act, 1989, parental responsibility for a child of unmarried parents rests with the mother. The father acquires it only when the statutory conditions are met.
- Section 8 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 treats the mother’s domicile as the domicile of origin of a child born outside wedlock.
- Nothing in the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 stops a mother from having a prima facie claim to custody of a child of tender age.
- The Court saw no reason to depart from this settled position, and treated international jurisprudence as an additional reason supporting the mother’s claim.
On the paramount consideration:
- In every custody dispute, the welfare and best interests of the child come first and override the parents’ competing claims.
On the balance of convenience:
- The mother had stayed in India for a long time despite her job in Singapore, which was affecting her work.
- If she could not return to Singapore, she might lose her job, and with it her ability to pay for the child’s education and well-being.
- A psychological assessment by NIMHANS found that both parents were capable of looking after the child.
- The mother’s plan for direct parenting time, schooling and the child’s overall development in Singapore was more concrete.
- The father argued that moving would uproot the child. The Court rejected this because the child had already lived in different cities and countries and had no exclusive roots anywhere.
- The father’s demanding work as a lawyer could leave the child largely in the care of relatives and nannies. The mother’s focus on direct parenting time gave the Court more confidence.
On irreparable injury:
- The child was likely to suffer irreparable injury if interim custody was not given to the mother.
Decision
- The mother was found to satisfy all three requirements of the interim relief test, and the child was placed in her interim custody.
- She was allowed to take the child to live with her in Singapore, subject to safeguards for the father’s access.
- During school vacations longer than seven days, the child must be brought to India to spend time with his father, paternal family and friends. The father will have custody for specified periods during these visits.
- The mother must help the child keep his connection with India through language, food and social interaction.
- She must also arrange periodic psychological assessments to make sure the child does not develop parental alienation against the father.
- The interim arrangement will not prejudice the Family Court, Patiala House Courts, which will decide permanent custody on its own.
What is Natural Guardianship under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956?
Meaning:
- A natural guardian is a person who is a guardian of a minor by law, by virtue of their relationship with the child, without any appointment by a court or by will.
- Under Section 4(a) of the Act, a “minor” is a person under 18 years of age.
Section 6 (Natural Guardians of a Hindu Minor):
The natural guardians of a Hindu minor, for both the minor’s person and the minor’s property (excluding an undivided interest in joint family property), are:
- (a) A boy or an unmarried girl: the father, and after him, the mother. Custody of a minor under five years of age is ordinarily with the mother.
- (b) An illegitimate boy or an illegitimate unmarried girl: the mother, and after her, the father.
- (c) A married girl: the husband.
Proviso to Section 6:
A person cannot act as the natural guardian of a minor if they:
- have ceased to be a Hindu; or
- have completely and finally renounced the world by becoming a hermit (vanaprastha) or an ascetic (yati or sanyasi).
Other Key Provisions:
- Section 7: The natural guardianship of an adopted son who is a minor passes, on adoption, to the adoptive father, and after him, to the adoptive mother.
- Section 8: Sets out the powers of a natural guardian. Court permission is needed before the guardian mortgages, sells, gifts or exchanges the minor’s immovable property.
- Section 13: When a court appoints or declares anyone as guardian of a Hindu minor, the welfare of the minor is the paramount consideration.
Welfare Principle under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890:
- Section 17 requires the court to be guided by the welfare of the minor when appointing a guardian. Relevant factors include the minor’s age, sex and religion, the character and capacity of the proposed guardian, and the minor’s own preference if the minor is old enough to form one.
