Home / Current Affairs

Civil Law

Section 92 CPC Suits

    «    »
 21-Nov-2026

    Tags:
  • Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC)

 Subhasindu Das v. Bacchu Ranjan Das 

A Section 92 CPC suit does not give every devotee an automatic right to be impleaded. 

Bench of Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh 

Source: Supreme Court 

Why in News? 

A three-judge bench of the Supreme Court, made up of Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh, decided Subhasindu Das & Ors. v. Bacchu Ranjan Das & Ors. (2026).  

The Court held that a suit under Section 92 CPC is representative in nature, but devotees or members of the institution are not automatically entitled to be impleaded. They must show sufficient grounds under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC. 

The Court set aside the Calcutta High Court's orders, including: 

  • an interim order staying the trial court's removal of a Special Officer; and 
  • orders setting aside the trial court's rejection of impleadment applications. 

What was the Background of  Subhasindu Das & Ors. v. Bacchu Ranjan Das & Ors. (2026) Case? 

The institution: 

  • Sri Guru Sangha is a charitable society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. Its central Ashram is in Kolkata. 

The suit: 

  • The appellants, who are members of the Sangha, filed a suit under Section 92 CPC seeking:  
    • removal of certain office bearers; 
    • framing of a scheme for management; and 
    • appointment of a receiver. 

Interim arrangements: 

  • While the suit was pending, the trial court appointed a Special Officer to oversee the Sangha's administration. 
  • After the plaintiffs complained of irregularities, the trial court removed the Special Officer by its order dated 07.06.2022. It set up a 13-member ad hoc committee and directed it to file quarterly reports and get annual audits. 
  • The High Court stayed this order by an interim order dated 26.09.2022. 
  • The Supreme Court stayed that interim order and later confirmed the protection. 

Impleadment applications: 

  • The trial court rejected the respondents' impleadment applications by a reasoned order dated 09.09.2025. 
  • The High Court set aside the rejection and allowed the applicants to file fresh applications. 
  • The Supreme Court stayed those orders in March 2026. 

What were the Court's Observations? 

Removal of the Special Officer: 

  • The trial court was competent to make interim arrangements for administering and protecting the Sangha. 
  • Appointment as Special Officer confers no vested right to continue in the position. 
  • The trial court had called for the Special Officer's written explanation and considered it. 
  • The ad hoc committee was set up on a joint application of the parties, with safeguards of periodic reports and audits. 
  • The High Court wrongly assumed that the Special Officer was removed without a hearing. It did not examine why the opportunity she was given was insufficient, and it identified no other infirmity. 

Limits of Article 227 jurisdiction: 

  • Relying on M/s Garment Craft v. Prakash Chand Goel, the Court restated that Article 227:  
    • is not meant to correct every error of fact or law; 
    • does not allow the High Court to substitute its own conclusions for those of the subordinate court; and 
    • justifies interference only where there is a patent jurisdictional error, perversity or grave miscarriage of justice. 
  • There was no sufficient justification for the High Court to stay the trial court's arrangement. 

Impleadment under Order I Rule 10(2): 

  • The court must decide whether the proposed party's presence is necessary or proper for the effective and complete adjudication of the suit. 
  • A Section 92 suit is representative and concerns everyone connected with the institution. Even so, this does not give every devotee or member an automatic right of impleadment. 
  • Applicants must show sufficient grounds for their separate participation and explain why their presence is necessary or proper. 
  • General allegations of collusion and mismanagement, without particulars, are not enough to justify impleadment. 
  • The High Court relied mainly on the representative nature of the suit. The Supreme Court said that this consideration is relevant, but it cannot, by itself, dispense with the requirements of Order I Rule 10(2). 
  • The High Court found no perversity in the trial court's findings. It also granted liberty to file fresh applications without dealing with the trial court's reasons. 

Plea for a fresh administrator: 

  • The respondents filed interlocutory applications alleging problems with how the ad hoc committee was working and managing finances, including donations expected during upcoming religious celebrations. They asked for an independent administrator or a fresh committee. 
  • The Court declined. It held that these allegations involve disputed questions that cannot properly be decided in these proceedings. 
  • The trial court still has jurisdiction over the suit and can examine irregularities and issue directions. Any grievance must be raised before it. 

 Decision of the Court: 

  • Civil Appeal Nos. 841 and 842 of 2023 were allowed. 
  • The High Court's common interim order dated 26.09.2022 in C.O. Nos. 2726 and 2334 of 2022 was set aside. 
  • The trial court's order dated 07.06.2022 will remain operative, subject to further orders of the competent court. 
  • The High Court's orders interfering with the rejection of the impleadment applications were also set aside. 
  • The Court clarified that its observations will have no bearing on the merits of the case. 

What is Section 92 of CPC? 

Section 92 of the CPC (Public Charities): 

Section 92(1): When a suit can be filed and by whom 

  • Applicability: It applies to an express or constructive trust created for public purposes of a charitable or religious nature. 
  • Grounds for the suit:  
    • an alleged breach of such a trust; or 
    • a situation where the direction of the court is considered necessary for administering the trust. 
  • Who may sue:  
    • the Advocate-General; or 
    • two or more persons having an interest in the trust, after getting the leave of the court. 
  • Nature of the suit: It may be filed whether it is contentious or not. 
  • Forum: The suit lies in the principal Civil Court of original jurisdiction, or in any other court the State Government has empowered for this purpose. That court must have local jurisdiction over the whole or any part of the trust's subject-matter. 

Reliefs available under Section 92(1) 

  • (a) removing any trustee 
  • (b) appointing a new trustee 
  • (c) vesting any property in a trustee 
  • (cc) directing a removed trustee, or a person who is no longer a trustee, to hand over possession of trust property to the person entitled to it (inserted by Act 66 of 1956) 
  • (d) directing accounts and inquiries 
  • (e) declaring what share of the trust property, or of an interest in it, goes to a particular object of the trust 
  • (f) authorising the whole or part of the trust property to be let, sold, mortgaged or exchanged 
  • (g) settling a scheme 
  • (h) granting any further or other relief the nature of the case requires 

Section 92(2): Bar on other suits 

  • A suit claiming any relief listed in sub-section (1) for such a trust can be filed only in conformity with Section 92(1). 
  • There is an exception for cases covered by the Religious Endowments Act, 1863, or any corresponding law in force in the former Part B State territories. 

Section 92(3): Cy-près doctrine 

  • The court may alter the original purposes of the trust. It may then allow the trust's property or income, in whole or in part, to be applied cy-près, meaning for purposes as close as possible to the original ones. 
  • The court can do this in the following circumstances:  
    • (a) the original purposes, in whole or in part:  
    • have been fulfilled as far as possible; or 
    • cannot be carried out at all, or cannot be carried out as the trust instrument directs (or, where there is no instrument, according to the spirit of the trust); 
    • (b) the original purposes use only part of the trust property; 
    • (c) the trust property can be used more effectively together with other property meant for similar purposes, keeping the spirit of the trust in mind; 
    • (d) the original purposes were tied to an area that was once a unit for those purposes but is no longer one; 
    • (e) since they were laid down, the original purposes have:  
      • been adequately provided for by other means; 
      • ceased because they are useless or harmful to the community; 
      • ceased to be charitable in law; or 
      • ceased in any other way to be a suitable and effective way of using the trust property, keeping the spirit of the trust in mind.