-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
List of Current Affairs
Home / List of Current Affairs
Civil Law
Children Can Appeal Against Eviction Orders Under Senior Citizens Act
04-Nov-2026
Source: Allahabad High Court
Why in News?
A bench of Justice Prakash Padia and Justice Indrajeet Shukla of the Allahabad High Court decided Dr. Upasana Giri v. State of U.P. and 4 Others (2026). The Court held that an appeal by children against an eviction order under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 is maintainable under Section 16. It disposed of the writ petition and sent the petitioner to the District Magistrate, Prayagraj, to file her appeal there.
What was the Background of Dr. Upasana Giri v. State of U.P. (2026) Case?
- The Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM), Tehsil Sadar, Prayagraj, passed an order dated 3rd October 2026 in proceedings under Section 7(1) of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007.
- The petitioner, Dr. Upasana Giri, is the child of respondent no. 5. She challenged the order through a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court.
- During the hearing:
- the State cited several judgments of the Allahabad High Court and other High Courts that took different views on whether children can appeal against eviction orders under the Act,
- the State also relied on the Division Bench judgment in Akhilesh Kumar v. State of UP (2019), and
- counsel for the Union of India told the Court that the central legislature is considering whether to give children a right of appeal, but no decision has been finalised yet.
Question before the High Court:
- Section 16 of the Act gives the right of appeal only to senior citizens and parents. Can children who are aggrieved by an eviction order passed by the Tribunal under the Act also appeal before the Appellate Tribunal?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On Section 16 of the Act:
- The Court accepted that on a plain reading, Section 16 does not show that children aggrieved by an eviction order can file an appeal.
- However, in Akhilesh Kumar v. State of UP (2019), a Division Bench had read the provision purposively. Its aim was to avoid flagrant discrimination between senior citizens or parents on one side and children on the other, which would happen if only one side had a right of appeal.
On the precedents relied upon:
- In Akhilesh Kumar, the High Court had relied on:
- Paramjit Kumar Saroya v. Union of India (Punjab and Haryana High Court), and
- Balamurugan v. Rukmani (Madras High Court).
- Both judgments held that Section 16(1) should be read purposively and that both sides have a right of appeal.
- A later decision of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Rita Roy v. Maintenance Tribunal and Sub Divisional Officer also held that an appeal by children aggrieved by an eviction order is maintainable.
- In view of these decisions, the Court saw no reason to take a different view.
On the doctrine of stare decisis:
- Sitting as a Division Bench, the Court followed Akhilesh Kumar to keep the law consistent, as the doctrine of stare decisis requires.
On the facts of the case:
- The petitioner was willing to approach the appellate authority, so the Court sent her to the District Magistrate, Prayagraj.
- The Court allowed her to file an appeal, along with an application for interim relief, within three days.
- If both were filed within that time, the District Magistrate had to decide the interim relief application on or before 16th November 2026.
- The District Magistrate was directed to hear all parties and decide the entire appeal within 30 days of its filing, as Section 16(6) of the Act requires.
- The Court recorded an undertaking by counsel for respondent no. 5 that the respondent would not seek or press for eviction until the interim relief application was decided. Because of this undertaking, the Court found no need to grant any further protection.
On the merits of the SDM’s order:
- The Court made clear that it had not decided the challenge to the SDM’s order on the merits.
- It allowed the appeal to be filed without interfering with the order dated 3rd October 2026, leaving the appellate authority free to examine the facts and the law independently.
Decision:
- The Court held that an appeal by children against an eviction order under the Act is maintainable.
- The writ petition was disposed of, and the petitioner was sent to the appellate authority.
What is Section 16 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007?
About:
- Section 16 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 provides for appeals against orders of the Maintenance Tribunal.
- Section 16(1): A senior citizen or parent aggrieved by an order of the Tribunal may appeal to the Appellate Tribunal within sixty days from the date of the order.
- While the appeal is pending, the children or relatives ordered to pay maintenance must keep paying it as directed.
- The Appellate Tribunal may hear an appeal filed after sixty days if there was sufficient cause for the delay.
- Section 16(2) to (4): On receiving an appeal, the Appellate Tribunal issues notice to the respondent, may call for the record of the proceedings from the Tribunal, and may allow or reject the appeal after examining it and the record.
- Section 16(5): The Appellate Tribunal decides the appeal, and its order is final.
- Section 16(6): The Appellate Tribunal must try to pronounce its order in writing within one month of receiving the appeal.
Key Features:
- Text gives the right to one side: On a plain reading, only a senior citizen or parent can appeal under Section 16(1).
- Purposive reading: Several High Courts, including the Allahabad, Punjab and Haryana, Madras and Chhattisgarh High Courts, have read the provision so that children aggrieved by an order, especially an eviction order, can also appeal.
- Avoiding discrimination: Giving only one side a right of appeal would be flagrant discrimination between parents and children.
- Speedy disposal: The Act aims for quick relief, so the Appellate Tribunal is expected to decide appeals within one month.
Civil Law
Competitor Cannot Challenge Grant of Registration under Insecticides Act
04-Nov-2026
Source: Supreme Court
Why in News?
A bench of Justice M.M. Sundresh and Justice Prasanna B. Varale of the Supreme Court decided Crystal Crop Protection Ltd v. Dhanuka Agritech Ltd & Ors. (2026). The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Delhi High Court Division Bench’s judgment, and restored the registration certificate granted to Crystal Crop Protection under the Insecticides Act, 1968.
What was the Background of Crystal Crop Protection Ltd v. Dhanuka Agritech Ltd (2026) Case?
- The Registration Committee granted Crystal Crop Protection (the appellant) a registration certificate under Section 9(3) of the Insecticides Act, 1968.
- The registration allowed the appellant to:
- import Halosulfuron methyl technical, and
- manufacture its formulation in India.
- Dhanuka Agritech Ltd (the respondent), a commercial competitor, challenged the registration before the appellate/revisional authority under Sections 10 and 11 of the Act.
- That challenge was rejected, and the respondent then approached the Delhi High Court.
- The Single Judge upheld the registration granted to the appellant.
- The Division Bench reversed that decision and quashed the registration certificate.
- The appellant then appealed to the Supreme Court.
Question before the Supreme Court:
- Can a commercial competitor challenge the grant of a registration certificate to another company under Section 10 of the Insecticides Act, 1968, and how far can a High Court go in judicial review of such a grant?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On Section 10 of the Insecticides Act, 1968:
- The Court said Section 10 provides an appeal only against a decision refusing registration or cancelling an existing registration.
- A commercial competitor cannot use this provision to challenge a registration certificate granted to another company.
- Section 10 applies only to decisions of refusal or cancellation, and these decisions must be communicated to the person who is entitled to challenge them.
On the expression “any person aggrieved”:
- The respondent relied on the words “any person aggrieved” in Section 10.
- The Court rejected this argument. It held that the expression must be read in the context of the specific decisions against which the provision allows an appeal.
- The respondent, as a commercial competitor, therefore could not be treated as “a person aggrieved” entitled to appeal under Section 10.
On the limits of judicial review:
- The Court said judicial review of executive decisions is limited, especially decisions granting licences to commercial entities.
- The Division Bench had overturned the conclusions of the statutory authorities, which the Single Judge had already upheld.
- In doing so, the High Court had in effect acted as an appellate authority and gone beyond the permissible limits of judicial review.
On the scrutiny done before registration:
- The Court took note of the Union Government’s affidavit, which set out the scrutiny carried out before the registration was granted.
- This included laboratory testing, which found the product’s purity to be 98.53%.
Decision:
- The Court held that the High Court’s judgment could not be sustained, either in law or on the merits.
- The appeal was allowed.
- The registration certificate granted to the appellant was restored.
What are Sections 9, 10 and 11 of the Insecticides Act, 1968?
About:
- The Insecticides Act, 1968 regulates the import, manufacture, sale, transport, distribution and use of insecticides. Its aim is to prevent risk to human beings and animals.
- The Act sets up the Central Insecticides Board to advise the Government, and the Registration Committee to register insecticides.
Section 9 – Registration of Insecticides:
- Any person who wants to import or manufacture an insecticide must apply to the Registration Committee to have it registered.
- Section 9(3): The Committee may register the insecticide after an inquiry, once it is satisfied about the insecticide’s efficacy and its safety to human beings and animals. It then allots a registration number and issues a certificate of registration.
- If the Committee refuses registration, it must communicate its decision to the applicant.
Section 10 – Appeal:
- Section 10 provides for an appeal to the Central Government against decisions of the Registration Committee.
- As the Supreme Court interpreted it in this case, the appeal lies only against:
- a decision refusing registration, or
- a decision cancelling an existing registration (cancellation is dealt with under Section 14).
- The appeal must be filed within the prescribed period, which runs from the date the decision is communicated to the person concerned.
Section 11 – Revision:
- Section 11 gives the Central Government revisional powers over proceedings of the Registration Committee under the Act.
Key Features:
- Registration is mandatory: No insecticide can be imported or manufactured without registration under the Act.
- Safety and efficacy are the tests: The Registration Committee decides registration based on scientific scrutiny of the insecticide’s efficacy and its safety to humans and animals.
- Limited right of appeal: The appeal under Section 10 is designed for a person affected by refusal or cancellation of registration, usually the applicant or the holder of the registration.
- No locus for competitors: A commercial competitor is not a “person aggrieved” under Section 10 and cannot appeal against registration granted to a rival.
