-
- Books & Magazines
- Login
- Language: Eng हिंदी
List of Current Affairs
Home / List of Current Affairs
Criminal Law
Employees of Government Companies Not Automatically Entitled to Sanction Protection
05-Nov-2026
Source: Supreme Court
Why in News?
A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar of the Supreme Court decided Jodhpur Discoms v. Lalit Soni & Anr. Etc. (2026). The Court allowed the appeal and set aside the Rajasthan High Court’s order that had discharged three Jodhpur Discom employees because no prior sanction had been obtained under Section 197 CrPC (now Section 218 BNSS). It held that employees of government companies are not automatically entitled to sanction protection.
What was the Background of Jodhpur Discoms v. Lalit Soni & Anr. Etc. (2026) Case?
- Three employees of Jodhpur Discoms were accused of abetting electricity theft by Balim Steel Pvt. Ltd. through meter tampering. They were:
- an Executive Engineer,
- an Assistant Engineer, and
- a Junior Engineer.
- The prosecution alleged that the company had made about ₹12.99 crore from the theft, and ₹8.15 crore of that was still unpaid.
- After investigation, a charge sheet was filed, the court took cognizance of the offence, and charges were framed under the Electricity Act, 2003.
- The employees filed revision petitions before the Rajasthan High Court.
- The High Court allowed the petitions and set aside the cognizance order. It held that prior sanction under Section 197 CrPC had not been obtained.
- Jodhpur Discoms then appealed to the Supreme Court.
Question before the Supreme Court:
- Can employees of a government company or public sector undertaking, who are deemed public servants, claim protection under Section 197 CrPC (now Section 218 BNSS) and require prior sanction before they are prosecuted?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On the status of the employees:
- The Court noted that the three employees were public servants under Section 169 of the Electricity Act, 2003.
- However, they were employees of Jodhpur Discoms. The State Government had not appointed them and could not terminate them.
On Section 197 CrPC protection:
- The Court held that an employee of a government instrumentality does not automatically become a government servant entitled to Section 197 CrPC protection just because they are a public servant.
- Being a “public servant” and being a person “not removable from office save by or with the sanction of the Government” are two separate things. Only the second attracts the sanction requirement under Section 197 CrPC (now Section 218 BNSS).
On Article 12 and government companies:
- Relying on Mohd. Hadi Raja v. State of Bihar (1998) and Punjab State Warehousing Corporation v. Bhushan Chander (2016), the Court repeated that officers of government companies and public undertakings are not entitled to Section 197 CrPC protection merely because their organisations are ‘State’ under Article 12 of the Constitution.
On the High Court’s judgment:
- The Court held that the very basis of the High Court’s judgment, which gave the respondents protection under Section 197 CrPC, was flawed because it went against the settled precedent of the Supreme Court.
Decision:
- The appeal was allowed.
- The High Court’s orders discharging the Executive Engineer, Assistant Engineer and Junior Engineer were set aside.
- The revision petitions were sent back to the High Court to be decided on the merits, including whether the charge sheet material justified framing charges against them.
What is Section 197 of CrPC / Section 218 of BNSS?
About:
- Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has been replaced by Section 218 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which came into force on 1st July 2024.
- The case was decided under Section 197 CrPC because the proceedings began when the CrPC was still in force. The principle applies equally to Section 218 BNSS.
- The provision protects judges, magistrates and certain public servants from prosecution without prior sanction from the appropriate government.
- Its purpose is to protect honest officers from frivolous or vexatious prosecution for acts done in the course of their official duties.
Section 218(1) BNSS (earlier Section 197(1) CrPC) – Prosecution of Judges and Public Servants:
- The protection applies when:
- the accused is, or was, a Judge, a Magistrate, or a public servant not removable from office save by or with the sanction of the Government, and
- the offence is alleged to have been committed while acting, or purporting to act, in the discharge of official duty.
- In such cases, no court can take cognizance of the offence without previous sanction from:
- the Central Government, if the person is or was employed in connection with the affairs of the Union, or
- the State Government, if the person is or was employed in connection with the affairs of a State.
Key Change under BNSS:
- Section 218 BNSS adds a timeline: the sanctioning authority must decide on a request for sanction within 120 days. If it does not, sanction is deemed to have been accorded.
Constitutional Law
Transit Remand Not Mandatory if Accused Produced Within 24 Hours
05-Nov-2026
Source: Andhra Pradesh High Court
Why in News?
A Division Bench of Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari and Justice Alapati Giridhar of the Andhra Pradesh High Court decided Sabena Prakash v. State of Andhra Pradesh & Others (2026). The Court dismissed the habeas corpus petition and upheld the remand order passed by the jurisdictional Magistrate. It held that not getting a transit remand does not, by itself, violate Article 22(2) of the Constitution if the arrested person is produced before the jurisdictional Magistrate within 24 hours.
What was the Background of Sabena Prakash v. State of Andhra Pradesh & Others (2026) Case?
- The case came out of a long-running property dispute in Karnataka between the detenue and another person, which had led to civil litigation and several criminal cases.
- Against this background, the Andhra Pradesh Police registered a separate criminal case in Andhra Pradesh over offences connected to the same property dispute.
- The detenue was named as an accused on a conspiracy allegation, although:
- he was not physically present at the place of occurrence, and
- the FIR did not attribute any overt act to him.
- The Andhra Pradesh Police arrested him in Karnataka and took him to Andhra Pradesh without getting a transit remand from a Magistrate in Karnataka.
- Within 24 hours of the arrest, he was produced before the Magistrate in Andhra Pradesh who had jurisdiction over the case, and was remanded to judicial custody.
- His wife (the petitioner) filed a habeas corpus petition before the High Court. She argued that the police should have produced him before the nearest Magistrate in Karnataka before taking him to Andhra Pradesh.
- A separate complaint of illegal apprehension and assault had also been filed with the Karnataka Police.
- The State of Andhra Pradesh argued that:
- the detenue was produced before the jurisdictional Magistrate within the time the Constitution prescribes,
- transit remand was not mandatory in these circumstances, and
- neither Article 22(2) nor the BNSS had been violated.
Question before the High Court:
- Is a remand order invalid, and the detention illegal, if the police do not get a transit remand from the nearest non-jurisdictional Magistrate after arresting a person outside the jurisdiction, but produce the person before the jurisdictional Magistrate within 24 hours?
What were the Court’s Observations?
On the expression “nearest Magistrate” in Article 22(2):
- The Court held that “nearest Magistrate” does not necessarily refer to the distance from the place of arrest to a jurisdictional or non-jurisdictional Magistrate.
- “Nearest” refers to time: whether the arrested person can be produced before the jurisdictional Magistrate within 24 hours of arrest.
- A non-jurisdictional Magistrate may be physically closer than the jurisdictional Magistrate. Even so, if the police produce the arrested person before the jurisdictional Magistrate within 24 hours, there is no violation of fundamental rights.
On practical conditions:
- The Court explained that geography, transport facilities and road connectivity can mean a court that is farther away is reachable sooner than a nearer Magistrate who has no jurisdiction over the case.
On transit remand:
- The Court held that getting a transit remand is not mandatory for producing the arrested person before the jurisdictional Magistrate for remand.
- Not getting a transit remand does not, by itself, violate Article 22(2) or the relevant BNSS provisions, as long as the arrested person is produced before the jurisdictional Magistrate within 24 hours, excluding the necessary journey time.
On the grounds of arrest:
- The Court noted that, during the hearing, the petitioner confined her challenge to the failure to get a transit remand. She did not separately argue that the grounds of arrest had not been communicated.
- The Court recorded that the remand report containing the grounds of arrest had been served on the detenue and his family before the remand order was passed.
Decision:
- The remand order passed by the jurisdictional Magistrate was held valid.
- The detenue’s continued detention under that order was held lawful and not an illegal detention.
- The writ petition was dismissed.
What are Article 22(2) of the Constitution and the Related BNSS Provisions?
About:
- Article 22 of the Constitution protects persons against arbitrary arrest and detention. Along with Article 21, it forms the core of procedural safeguards for arrested persons.
- A person who claims to be illegally detained can seek a writ of habeas corpus from a High Court under Article 226 or from the Supreme Court under Article 32.
Article 22(1):
- An arrested person must be told the grounds of arrest as soon as possible.
- The arrested person has the right to consult, and be defended by, a legal practitioner of their choice.
Article 22(2):
- Every arrested and detained person must be produced before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours of arrest.
- The time needed for the journey from the place of arrest to the Magistrate’s court is excluded from the 24 hours.
- No such person can be detained beyond that period without the authority of a Magistrate.
Section 58 BNSS (earlier Section 57 CrPC) – Person Arrested Not to Be Detained More than 24 Hours:
- A police officer cannot detain a person arrested without a warrant for longer than is reasonable in the circumstances.
- That period cannot exceed 24 hours, excluding the time needed for the journey to the Magistrate’s court, unless the Magistrate orders otherwise.
Section 187 BNSS (earlier Section 167 CrPC) – Procedure when Investigation Cannot Be Completed in 24 Hours:
- If the investigation cannot be completed within 24 hours, the arrested person must be forwarded to the nearest Judicial Magistrate.
- The Magistrate may authorise the person’s detention, whether or not they have jurisdiction to try the case.
- A Magistrate without jurisdiction may authorise detention only for a limited period and must then send the accused to a Magistrate who has jurisdiction. In practice, this limited order is called a transit remand.
